Design critique is a systematic and constructive feedback process used to improve designs. An effective critique culture is the lifeblood of design teams.
Steps to organize an effective critique session:
- Define clear goals: 'Usability' or 'Visual consistency'
- Give the designer a voice: Allow them to explain design decisions
- Be specific: Not 'Looks bad' but 'This color contrast doesn't meet accessibility standards'
- Problem-focused, not solution-focused: Identify problems rather than suggesting solutions
- Critique the design, not the designer: Product-focused feedback, not personal
Feedback formula: 'This [element] creates [its effect] because of [reason]. Perhaps [alternative approach] could be considered?'
A good critique process creates better products and stronger design teams.